Those two businesses launched what is now an iconic New Haven pizza scene. It’s a charming origin story, but it’s not what makes apizza better than every other style of pizza across the country. Many people say it’s the best because of New Haven’s hard water, which makes the dough more elastic.
How do you make New Haven style pizza thin?
New Haven style pizza is very, very thin. It can be difficult to get dough very thin. Just keep kneading and flipping the dough. Press with your fingers in an outward motion to stretch the dough on the cutting board or pizza peel.
What is New Haven-style pizza?
It features a crust that is thin and crispy on the outside, but the dough is also chewy still on the inside. The traditional recipe calls for baking New Haven-style pizza in a coal oven, which is how the distinctive outer char occurs along the edges of the crust.
What is the difference between New York and New Haven pizza?
Characteristics. What makes New Haven style pizza distinct is its thin, oblong crust, characteristic charring, chewy texture, and limited use of melting cheeses. It tends to be drier and thinner than, but closely related to, traditional New York style pizza. Both styles in turn are close descendants of the original Neapolitan style.
What is New Haven pizza made out of?
It features the iconic New Haven-style pizza crust, mozzarella, basil, zucchini, and tomato slices that provide a glimpse of the traditional methods while catering to robust modern flavors. 3. Modern Apizza.
What makes a pizza New Haven?
What makes New Haven-style pizza distinct is its thin, oblong crust, characteristic charring, chewy texture, and limited use of melting cheeses. It tends to be drier and thinner than, but closely related to, traditional New York-style pizza. Both styles in turn are close descendants of the original Neapolitan pizza.
How is New Haven pizza different?
There’s a stark difference between the two crusts, owing to the longer fermentation process of New Haven’s dough. Proofed slowly overnight in the fridge, New Haven crust tends to be more complex in flavor than its oversized NYC counterpart.
Is New Haven pizza the best?
New Haven’s pizza scene is historic, diverse and nationally revered. New Haven’s reputation as a top pizza city is unassailable. National food experts rank its pizzerias at the top of annual awards lists.
Does New Haven have the best pizza?
New Haven-based Frank Pepe Pizza Napoletana has been named as the top pizza destination in the country, according to a new list published this month. The Daily Meal released a list of the top 101 Best Pizza in America and Frank Pepe’s came out on top.
Why is Connecticut pizza so good?
‘The New Haven-based pizzeria is famous for its signature coal-fired White Clam Pizza featuring fresh clams, grated pecorino romano, garlic, oregano and olive oil. Not only is Frank Pepe’s the top pizza destination in the country, but it’s also one of the greatest old-school restaurants of all time.’
What’s a Sicilian style pizza?
Traditional Sicilian pizza is often thick crusted and rectangular, but can also be round and similar to the Neapolitan pizza. It is often topped with onions, anchovies, tomatoes, herbs and strong cheese such as caciocavallo and toma. Other versions do not include cheese.
What is the best style of pizza?
Which Type of Pizza Is the Best?
- Sicilian Pizza. Sicilian-style pizzas are thick and bready, practically a focaccia with extra toppings.
- Neapolitan Pizza.
- Roman-Style Pizza.
- New York Thin Crust Pizza.
- Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza.
- New Haven-Style Clam Pizza.
- Detroit Red Top Pizza.
How is apizza different from pizza?
How Else Is Apizza Different From Regular Pizza? Another major difference is that unlike regular pizza, on which a layer of red sauce and a layer of shredded mozzarella cheese are assumed to adorn the crust, apizza will often dispense with both. A plain pie will have tomato sauce, plus garlic and parmesan.
What is New Haven Connecticut known for?
Perhaps best known as the home of Yale University, New Haven is the second largest city in Connecticut and the sixth largest in New England. You’ll find collegiate sports, major concert events, shops, museums, festivals, and 56 Zagat-rated restaurants – the most in Connecticut.
What is the best pizza in the world?
Top 14 Places In The World To Have The Best Pizza
Can you use 00 flour instead of all purpose?
Can You Substitute All-Purpose for 00 Flour? The simple answer is yes, you can. Many recipes that call for 00 flour will often call for all-purpose as a substitute. There shouldn’t be any problems using it in your favorite homemade cake, but you will notice a slightly chewier texture with the all-purpose.
What kind of cheese does Frank Pepe use?
The restaurant’s most traditional model, Frank Pepe’s Original Tomato Pie, is a red pizza with only tomatoes, grated pecorino cheese and olive oil, notably lacking mozzarella. I like it, but not everyone does, and tradition or no, it’s quite alright to add mozzarella.
What kind of cheese does Sallys use?
Sally’s “mozzarella” pizza is essentially a Margherita, although the dry American mozzarella made for pizza, and used in New Haven, tends to turn rubbery and a little heavy in the oven.
What is the best pizza New Haven CT?
What characterizes New Haven style pizza?
– Size – Pizzas are larger in diameter. – Crust – Not thin, and not Sicilian style; a New Haven crust is medium size, a bit on the doughy side, it gives you something to chew on. – Topping Quality/Quantity – Every New Haven pizza parlor has signature toppings or a specialty pizz
What is the oldest pizzeria in New Haven?
New Haven, CT (Est. 1925) The oldest New Haven pizza joint around (and one of the 33 best pizza shops in the country), Frank Pepe is considered ‘the big dog’ in town, and with two very good
Ken’s New Haven-Style Pizza Recipe
- Pizza was one of my favorite foods as a child.
- When I was growing up in New Haven, Connecticut, there were a plethora of excellent pizza places around.
- At the time, I didn’t know how unique they truly were, or how tough it is to make a truly delicious pizza from scratch.
- My research revealed that the secret to this dish’s rich tomato flavor lies in the use of tasty San Marzano tomatoes, pungent oregano, and a thin, crispy, and charred crust.
- New Haven pizza, in my opinion, necessitates more effort and more expensive ingredients.
- For example, you can taste the sauce and literally SEE it on the pizza as you cut into it.
In fact, the sauce is frequently so delicious that a popular New Haven Pizza is served bare, with no toppings other than the sauce.Often, the only thing you’ll find on a cheap pizza is heaps of low-quality cheese topping a thin layer of sauce.Perhaps New Yorkers are more concerned with speed and money than I am…but I’ll take a New Haven pizza any day.
New Haven pizza is also frequently charred, thanks to the coal-fired ovens that provide such delectable results.Because domestic ovens don’t get extremely hot, it’s unlikely that the home baker will be able to produce the charring effect, but we can come quite close with a little practice.Sauce was a favorite dish of my departed grandma.
My mother used to cultivate fresh basil in the garden and put it in the sauce, which was delicious.Excellent Italian food is frequently distinguished by the presence of a good sauce.It’s made even better by the use of fresh ingredients and robust spices.
Since relocating to Texas a few years ago, I have been dissatisfied with the quality of the local pizza.I made the decision to put on my oven gloves and head to the kitchen to make my own pizza — just the way I remember it from my youth – from scratch.However, despite the fact that I do not operate a New Haven pizza restaurant and that different establishments will have their own interpretations of what constitutes New Haven Pizza, this recipe is the closest I’ve gotten to reproducing the regional taste at home throughout my many years of preparing pizza.
- Bread flour (this adds extra elasticity to the dough mix) and 2 cups all-purpose flour (this provides the dough mix more elasticity). Bob’s Red Mill All Purpose Flour and Bob’s Red Mill Bread Flour are the flours I use.
- 1 packet of active yeast (regular, rapid-rise, or pizza-specific yeast) Red Star Yeast is the preferred kind.
- The ingredients are as follows: 2 tablespoons Mediterranean sea salt
- 1 big tablespoon malt (or 3 teaspoons sugar – Sugar in the Raw brand recommended)
- 2 2/3 cups somewhat warm filtered water
- 3.5 tablespoons extra-virgin olive oil
- 1 can of whole tomatoes (San Marzano) 1 can of diced tomatoes It is necessary to use Italian tomatoes in order to have a truly genuine flavour.
- A dusting of oregano
- a teaspoon of extra-virgin olive oil
- Moderately finely ground corn meal
- optional: mozzarella cheese (made from full milk, not skim). in the shape of a block
- Toss in some pepperoni (I favor Boar’s Head pepperoni from the butcher department of organic grocery shops, but you can also use regular Hormel’s Original Pepperoni from the freezer aisle if you can’t get to the butcher’s section.)
- Basil leaves (for sprinkling on top after baking – optional – this is not a New Haven hallmark, but it is Ken’s addition)
- Optional: sprinkling crushed red pepper on top after baking
Kitchen Items Needed
- A stainless steel bowl, a pizza peel, a pizza cutter, and a thick pizza stone are all required.
- The use of a wood or coal-fired oven imported from Naples (this is not necessary, but if you have an excess of money and plenty of room, why not?)
Ken is putting the finishing touches on the pizza.
Gimme the Dough
- To prevent flour from adhering to the bottom of a big stainless steel mixing bowl, spray the bowl with nonstick spray.
- Bring 3/4 cup of water to a boil and reduce to 120 degrees.
- It works for me to microwave 3/4 cup of water for 20 seconds at full power in a 1400 watt microwave for 20 seconds.
- You DO NOT want the water to be too hot, because otherwise the yeast will be killed.
- In a cup of warm water, combine the warm water, the yeast, and the malt (or sugar).
- When I’m mixing the yeast with the sugar and malt, I use a measuring cup.
Allow for at least 5-10 minutes of resting time.Because of the yeast, you should see around a.5 inch foam top form on top of the mixture.If no foam forms after a few minutes, either the yeast was destroyed by the boiling water or the yeast was no longer viable (check the expiration date on the box).Combine the flour, olive oil, and salt in a mixing bowl.
In a large mixing basin, combine the warm water and yeast mixture.Using a big spoon, stir the mixture.Add another 3/4 cup of warm water to the pot and stir well.
When the mixture begins to solidify, rub it together to form a ball.Bring the dough to a smooth, elastic consistency — not too dry, not too wet, but a bit on the moist side to allow the yeast rise more effectively.Cover the ball of dough in the mixing basin with plastic wrap and let it aside for 1-24 hours to rise.
A glass plate is my preferred method of covering the mixing bowl in order to view the dough rise.A typical day for me involves preparing the dough first, followed by preparing the pizza for baking later (about 6 hours later).If you are in a hurry, you may let the dough rise for only an hour; however, the longer you wait, the more flavor you will obtain.Make sure you follow the ingredient quantities to the letter.
- If you do, there will be no need to make any modifications.
- If the dough is too dry, a little additional water can be added.
- It may also require a small amount of more olive oil.
- If the dough is excessively moist, extra flour should be added.
- This sort of pizza is really difficult to prepare.
You’ll have to attempt several times before you get it correctly the first time.The most enjoyable part of this process is that once you’ve gotten the pizza just right, you can experiment with different toppings, ingredients, temperatures, and literally everything else to make each pizza a unique and different experience while still remaining under the delicious New Haven Pizza umbrella of course.When it comes to New Haven pizza, you’ll hear it referred to as ″Apizza″ or ″ahbeetz″ rather frequently.
Setup the Special Sauce
- Squash the entire San Marzano tomatoes in a basin with a spoon or potato masher until they are smooth.
- It has been my experience that putting the smashed / saucy tomatoes on the pizza cold gives the sauce a tangy, rich flavor that New Haveners are familiar with.
- It is possible to add oregano to the crushed tomatoes in the sauce pan.
- In addition, the wood- or coal-fired ovens featured in the eateries contribute to the truly distinctive flavor of the food.
- When it comes to oregano, some eateries go beyond, to the point where it can be seen all over their dishes and sauces.
- You may use a small amount of garlic, but be careful – garlic is quite pungent, and even a small amount can completely spoil the sauce.
I knead a Pizza
- To knead the dough, a wooden cutting board works well.
- There will be enough dough to make 4 mini pizzas from this batch.
- The crust of New Haven style pizza is extremely thin.
- It might be tough to roll out dough to a very thin layer.
- Just keep kneading and turning the dough until it comes together.
- Stretch the dough on the cutting board or pizza peel by pressing it outward with your fingers in an outward direction.
The dough has been stretched too thin if you are able to see through it at this point.Also keep in mind that the sauce and toppings will significantly weigh down the dough and may cause the pizza to adhere to the pizza peel.It’s possible that it’ll damage the pizza.This is when the magical properties of cornmeal come into play.
Place some cornmeal on a pizza peel and bake the pizza.This will make it easier to take off the peel (and adds a bit of flavor).Place the dough on the spatula once it has been rolled out thinly and into a pizza shape.
Ken’s Apizza with a Simple Sauce Spread the sauce on the dough with a wide spoon, making sure it is equally distributed.As I previously stated, sauce is very essential in New Haven’s culture.You can stuff the pizza as full as you like, but be cautious not to load it down too much, because then it will be difficult to slip it off the pizza peel.
Add your favorite toppings, but the sauce should take center stage.The San Marzano tomatoes give it a sweet flavor that pairs perfectly with the charred crust.Remove bits of mozzarella cheese from the block of whole-milk mozzarella cheese.Distribute the cheese chunks on the pizza in a uniform layer.
- Because the cheese will melt and spread, they do not need to be perfectly formed.
- If desired, top with pepperoni.
- Placing the pizza on a pizza stone is a good idea.
- Pizza screens are more durable than inexpensive pizza stones and allow more heat to pass through, resulting in a crispier crust while baking.
- Pricer pizza stones are fantastic, but they must be thick in order to be durable, and they require more time to preheat in the oven before they get hot.
Stone is my preferred cooking surface since it is akin to a traditional pizza oven.The crust of New Haven style pizza is a little crispier than the normal pizza dough with char.It will be crispier as a result of the thin crust.Preheat the oven to 350°F.
Preheat the pizza stone for a lengthy period of time if it is thick.It might take up to 40 minutes.Preheat the oven to 500 degrees for 13 minutes before placing the pizza in the oven.Crispiness may be affected by the location of the rack.If you’re adding cheese, be cautious not to put it on a high rack, because the cheese may begin to melt and burn.Make sure to keep an eye on your pizza throughout the last few minutes of baking.
If desired, garnish the finished pizza with basil leaves and crushed red pepper after it has been baked.
Home Outdoor Oven
- My brother just acquired an OONI outdoor pizza oven, which he generously allowed me to use.
- My pizza reached new heights thanks to the use of real coal and the extremely high temperatures made achievable by the oven.
- Coal and a hot oven are required if you want to make authentic New Haven pizza at home.
- If you have the necessary room and funds, as well as a strong desire to enjoy New Haven pizza, you should consider purchasing one.
- The coal flavor adds an unexplainable and genuinely one-of-a-kind depth to the experience.
- The coal oven is comprised of: As a result of this, Frank Pepe’s and Modern Apizza, as well as Tolli’s Apizza, are some of the most popular pizza restaurants in the city of New Haven.
Also, wash down the pizza with a refreshing beverage from the Foxon Park neighborhood – my personal favorite is White Birch.Make a point of stopping by when you’re in town.We would normally use a coal-fired oven to bake these pizzas, but we don’t have one right now.If you look around, you’ll find that most pizza places use only a small amount of sauce and smother the pie with cheese.
In my opinion, this is not the wisest course of action.New Haven is well-known for its pizza, and it is also a favorite of President Clinton and other notable figures in the community.Hope you and your family love this dish and make this pizza from a tiny city in Connecticut a regular part of your family’s mealtime rituals.
A slightly charred pizza with yellow bell peppers, Boar’s Head Pepperoni, and Mozzarella cheese made by Ken’s New Haven Pizza (2019).
New Haven Pizza Tweak – Naples Pizza:
- Because New Haven pizza is a variant of the pizza from Naples, Italy, and because many New Haven Italians are descended from the Naples area, you might be interested in cooking a Naples version of the dish instead. It has a wonderful flavor as a result of the use of Italian ingredients and the rigorous adherence to pizza-making standards. Make modifications to my current recipe by using the following ingredients: 4 cups 00 flour (imported from Italy)
- Italian Yeast
- fresh basil leaves on top
- Mozzarella is arranged in big circular slices on a serving plate.
I’ve tried pizza in every part of Italy, and my favorite is the pizza from Naples. It’s a little fluffier and chewier than New Haven pizza, but it still has that char that we all love so much about it.
New Haven Pizza Experience
In this documentary, Frank Pinello discovers New Haven pizza, sometimes known as ″Apizza.″
New Haven-Style Pizza: A Delicious Gem From The Constitution State
- If you are familiar with the cities of Chicago or New York, you will know that the kind of pizza served there is an iconic aspect of the city’s image.
- The same may be stated about the city of New Haven in the state of Connecticut.
- Restaurants, operators, and the home cooks who prepare it are doing much more than just preparing a quick meal for their customers.
- They are working together to ensure that their legacy is preserved.
What Is New Haven-Style Pizza?
- A slice of ″apizza,″ which you pronounce like ″ah-beets,″ is what you’re eating when you visit New Haven to sample a piece of pizza.
- It has a thin and crispy crust on the exterior, but the dough is still chewy on the inside, thanks to the use of whole wheat flour.
- New Haven-style pizza is traditionally baked in a coal oven, which results in the unique outer char that appears along the edges of the dough that distinguishes this kind of pizza from others.
- Using a heated broiler, some operators have been able to achieve a similar outcome.
- When you order apizza, the toppings are limited, so you never have to worry about having too much sauce or cheese on your plate.
- Each dough is individually molded to get the desired effect, therefore you will see them in a range of sizes and configurations as well.
What Makes New Haven Style Different That Other Pizza Types?
- There are two varieties of Connecticut pizza that are unique to the New Haven area: plain tomato and white.
- Plain tomato is the most common variety of Connecticut pizza.
- Some restaurants specialize on a single type of pizza, but more and more are offering the ability to pick from a number of options and to personalize your toppings as well.
- The first choice combines garlic and Parmesan with a fresh tomato sauce for a flavorful combination.
- To get mozzarella cheese, you will need to request it because in this location, it is regarded a topping rather than a food item.
- Make sure to ask for the ″Mootz″ pie if you want one!
Choose the white pie, and you will receive garlic, mozzarella, Parmesan, and oregano in an olive oil base, along with the rest of the ingredients.A fresh littleneck clam apizza such as this one is a great way to get a flavor of New England without leaving the country.
Well-Known Restaurants Who Serve New Haven-Style Pizza
- As more and more people become aware that they are eating ″apizza″ rather than a standard pizza slice, businesses all across the United States begin to notice that this unique Connecticut-style pizza is becoming increasingly popular with their local market.
- It is a genuinely unique dining experience since it is normally a well-done pizza, and the freshly baked components make it even more so.
- The art of making New Haven-style pizza has been refined over the years by a number of outstanding establishments.
- If you have never tried an apizza before, this is the list of places you should go to taste it.
- In this restaurant, which is a family-owned company, the recipes have stayed virtually unchanged for nearly a century.
- Gary Bimonte, who is the grandson of the original Pepe, is the current owner of the business.
- They were the first to introduce the notion of apizza to the state of Connecticut, and their dedication to tradition is reflected in their menu options.
- They are also pioneers in the development of novel apizza tastes, having been the first to use clams on a pizza, among other accomplishments.
- There was a man in New Haven who, according to the account, was selling raw littlenecks in an alley near their restaurant.
- The Pepe family planned to include them as an appetizer at first, but the item quickly grew so popular that it was forced to be included as a topping to the dish as well.
Pepe’s is now consuming up to 80 bushels of clams every week while also providing some of the greatest pizza in the New Haven region.
2. Sally’s Apizza.
- The site of this operator is directly across the street from the first Pepe’s establishment.
- This restaurant gives off a retro atmosphere to its customers, to the extent where they only accept cash as payment for their meals.
- Locals are always debating which one is superior, but the queue that snakes down the block on any given day appears to put an end to the dispute.
- Come to Sally’s for a slice of their famous tomato pie.
- In addition to the renowned New Haven-style pizza dough, it also includes mozzarella and basil as well as zucchini and tomato slices, all of which offer a glimpse of ancient ways while still appealing to bold current flavors.
3. Modern Apizza.
- This business is located in the same neighborhood as Sally’s and Pepe’s, but they differ from the norm by employing a wood-fired pizza oven rather than a coal-fired oven.
- There are also other topping alternatives to pick here, as well as a typical Italian menu to match the apizza selections that you may order.
- Because it takes a more contemporary approach to New Haven-style pizza, the wait time is a little less here than at other places.
- It is recommended that you sample the Italian Bomb on your first visit.
- It has seven typical toppings that include pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and other delicious ingredients.
- Although this business is one of the newest in the region to serve New Haven pizza, the fact that it is so young should not be construed as a disadvantage.
- It has a brick oven fueled by natural gas, produces its own beer on site, and transforms into a nightclub after regular eating hours.
- It is possible to order either the tomato or the white apizza choices here, with or without mozzarella depending on your preferences.
- They also offer 30 various toppings that you may choose from while placing your order, with mashed potatoes being one of the most popular options.
5. Zuppardi’s Apizza.
- It is recommended that you give this operator an opportunity to surprise you if the thought of the littleneck clam New Haven-style pizza appeals to you.
- Instead of cutting the clams for the topping, they arrange entire clams on top of the pie and serve it with slices of lemon on the side.
- You may also add a fresh, handmade sausage to your sandwich as a topper.
- If you happen to be in the vicinity, keep in mind that parking might be a bit difficult during the lunch rush.
- If you like, you may also place an order for pick-up.
- You’ll also be in West Haven while working with this third-generation company, so be sure to spend some time exploring Union Avenue during your time there as well.
Why People Love New Haven-Style Pizza
- Because of the original Pepe’s training in Italy in 1909, New Haven-style pizza was inspired by the classic Neopolitan approach to this dish.
- This apizza is frequently regarded as the greatest form of pizza to be found in the United States.
- When given the choice between this version and other popular selections such as Chicago or New York, there are a few factors that influence people’s decision to choose it.
1. You can order a wider variety of ingredients.
New Haven-style pizza employs a straightforward approach that prioritizes your own tastes above everything else. Only a few other restaurants on the planet provide potatoes, littleneck clams, and other seafood toppings that have been caught only minutes before.
2. It brings people together.
People in Connecticut get together over a slice of pizza. Whether you eat it with a fork and knife or try to pick it up to take a piece, apizza is a meal that requires you to take your time. It brings families or groups of friends together around the table to speak about their days and have a great time together.
3. The dough is quite elastic.
Although the crust is crispy on the outside, the dough for New Haven pizza is unusually springy. Although this may be attributed to the mineral composition of the local water supply, the style also undergoes a more prolonged fermenting process than the types produced in Chicago or New York.
- Pizza in New Haven is a unique culinary experience that everyone should have the opportunity to have at least once in their lives.
- Taking the apizza route may seem a little unusual at first, but you will soon realize that the Connecticut version of the world’s most popular pie is one of the best available.
- The tastes are out of this world, whether you want to sample one with clams, one with more mozzarella, or something ″simple″ with Romano cheese, olive oil, and tomatoes.
The Mystique and Magic of New Haven-Style Pizza
- During her visit to the PMQ Test Kitchen, Gail Churinetz of Gail’s Pizza Parties prepared a classic New Haven Tomato Pie using fresh ingredients.
- Daniel Lee Perea’s full name is Daniel Lee Perea.
- New Haven, Connecticut, claims to be the origin of the hamburger and is also home to some of the world’s greatest pizza.
- The city was founded by the Puritans 360 years ago and claims to be the birthplace of the hamburger.
- In the early 1920s, according to local folklore, Neapolitan immigrant Frank Pepe started manufacturing pizzas, which were then known as tomato pies, and selling them to nearby industrial employees from a pushcart.
- Pepe acquired a building with a brick oven in 1925, and he began selling his pies from that site the following year.
Over the years, two additional New Haven-style pizzerias opened their doors: Modern Apizza (formerly known as Tony’s Apizza) in 1934 and Sally’s Apizza in 1938, both of which have become landmarks in the city.New Haven style pizza is known as apizza in the area and is pronounced ″ah-beetz.″ It is a thin-crust pizza that is baked at high temperatures in a coal-fired or oil-fired brick oven and served in an irregular or oblong form.New Haven-style pizza is a near relative of the traditional New York style, having origins in the Neapolitan tradition.However, there are minor variances between the two that distinguish it from the classic New York style.
Our success is due to our adherence to my grandfather’s exact recipes, which we follow to the letter.All of this is based on tradition.″ Chef Gary Bimonte of Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana in New York City
Lightly Charred and Crispy
- The dough for New Haven-style pizza is allowed to rise for a longer period of time than typical pizza dough, and the flour used has a lower protein concentration than traditional pizza flour—around 13 percent.
- ″New Haven-style pizza is recognized for being a little crispier than most,″ says Erica Pustari, manager of Modern Apizza.
- ″It’s also known for being a little crispier than most.″ ″It’s because there’s too much water in the dough.″ Because we are using mother yeast, we must refrigerate and cover the dough while it rises for a longer period of time.
- ″It’s always fermenting and living,″ says the author.
- In addition, the baking technique differs between the Neapolitan and New York versions.
- The pie bakes for a longer period of time than other varieties since the oven temperature is near to 1000 degrees.
The end result is a crispy pie with a hint of char on the bottom of the crust.″If you’re a traditionalist when it comes to baking New Haven-style pizzas, coal-fired ovens are high on the list,″ says industry consultant Tom ″The Dough Doctor″ Lehmann, who is based in Manhattan, Kansas.″When it comes to baking New Haven-style pizzas, coal-fired ovens rank high on the list if you’re a traditionalist.″ ″While other types of ovens can be used effectively, coal-fired ovens have been the conventional method of cooking for centuries.″ According to Gary Bimonte, grandson of Frank Pepe and proprietor of Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, coal has a number of advantages over wood in terms of cooking efficiency.″Coal burns at 1,000 degrees Celsius, while wood burns at 600 to 700 degrees Celsius,″ Bimonte explains.
″Wood produces a wet heat, whereas coal produces a high, intense, dry heat, which tends to lock in all of the ingredients and give the pizza its distinctive sear.″ ″That’s what Frank Pepe’s is renowned for,″ says the owner.Modern Apizza’s oven was initially heated with coke, a byproduct of coal, but the company moved to an oil-burning oven around 1967 owing to a scarcity of coke at the time.″There’s certainly a tiny touch of charcoal in New Haven pizza,″ adds Pustari.
″You used a deeper color on the margins, didn’t you?″ It’s not really doughy, but it is crispy—not too crunchy, but with a taste of raw brick to it—and it is not too sweet.The flavor of food prepared in an oil oven will differ from that of food prepared in a wood-fired oven.When you cook with wood fire, you get that woody, smokey flavor, but when you work with an oil-based oven, it’s an entirely different beast because of the manner that the pizza is cooked in the oven.
It’s more focused on the pizza itself rather than on the woody flavoring of the sauce.It’s all about the dough in this game.This would detract from the flavor of the dough because of the smokiness of the wood.″ ″If you’re a purist when it comes to creating New Haven-style pizzas, coal-fired ovens are at the top of the list.″ ― Tom Lehmann, aka ″The Dough Doctor″
Family and Tradition
- The White Clam Pizza is a New Haven institution and a must-try.
- It all started in the 1940s when Pepe topped a pizza with clams, which were a popular appetizer at the time, and topped it with olive oil, garlic, and oregano.
- The baking process combined those components with the clam liquid, resulting in a sauce that was almost self-contained.
- ″Our White Clam Pizza has been honored three years in a row, and it has been named the finest in the country,″ Bimonte explains.
- Tradition and family are the last, albeit intangible, parts of the New Haven pizza style, and they are both important.
- Modern Apizza is still family-owned, although Frank Pepe’s is owned by a corporate board of directors that is also family-owned.
According to Bimonte, ″I have three sisters and three cousins, which makes a total of seven of us.″ ″The family retains a strong grip over the situation.Despite the fact that we have a corporate entity—Frank Pepe’s Development Firm—and that all of our sites are owned by the company, we are still a family-owned business at heart.Outside investors are present, but everything is under the management of the development business.Pustari argues that it is the intimate familial relationships that distinguish New Haven pizza from other types of pizza.
″Modern is a family-owned business, and my mother is originally from Italy, so the cuisine is a little more authentic since it comes from the same family and has the same origins.″ And these New Haven apizza families have no intention of tampering with their own success.″There’s not a single thing the family is altering,″ Bimonte asserts.Our success is due to our adherence to my grandfather’s exact recipes, which we follow to the letter.
All of this is based on tradition.″ Bill DeJournett contributes to the PMQ blog.
The Definitive Guide to New Haven Pizza
A New Haven Pizza Lexicon
It’s apizza, not pizza
The term ″apizza″ is a distinctive attribute of the city of New Haven in and of itself. The letter ″a″ is a forerunner of the Italian dialect that is spoken in the area of Naples. Sally’s and Modern are still pleased to use it, and a few other establishments in the vicinity do so as a reverent homage to their aesthetic New Haven origins as well.
Coal was plentiful and inexpensive during the 1920s and 1930s. It is also responsible for the flavor of the pies at Pepe’s and Sally’s, which is blistered, sooty, and smoke-infused to this day. Modern cooking was also initially based on coal, in the form of coke fuel, but has subsequently transitioned to an open flame brick oven that is fuelled by oil.
It’s not burned, it’s charred
Regardless of the fuel used, every apizza is made in highly hot brick ovens with pies left on their decks for an extended period of time, resulting in a distinctively deep-charred crust that distinguishes it from the competition. Some may refer to it as ″burned,″ but that is incorrect: in New Haven, it is referred to as ″charred.″
A long, cold fermentation
- The fermentation time for New Haven-style pizza dough is significantly longer than that of its fast rise New York-style pizza neighbor.
- Allowing the dough to prove more slowly over the period of an overnight refrigerator, in combination with allowing the dough to come to room temperature before shaping and baking, results in a much more nuanced taste and chewy crust than baking the dough immediately after mixing it.
Most of the old timers in New Haven refer to their whole milk matured mozzarella as ″mootz,″ which is pronounced as ″mootz.″ If you 1) grew up using the phrase, 2) are Italian American and want to give it a go, or 3) work in a pizza and/or have flour on your shirt, you can get away with it on or near Wooster Street. If you don’t, you’ll get arrested.
“Mootz” is a topping
Because mozzarella is considered a topping, make careful to say ″mootz″ or ″no mootz″ when ordering. If you don’t specifically request it, it will not be included on your pizza.
- The earliest pies created in New Haven were covered with tomato sauce, as is still the case today.
- That’s all there is to it.
- Instead of rivers of cheese and a smattering of toppings, this dish relies on the simple heat of the oven to cook fresh and tart hand crushed tomatoes.
- For those who prefer light or no cheese to enjoy the simplicity of New Haven’s acidic tomato sauce and charred crust, light or no cheese is still the preferred option, and now practically all New Haven pizza parlors offer their own spin on the classic.
White clam pizza
It is possible to find a nice white clam pie at any New Haven pizza shop worthy of its zip code. After all, Pepe is the one who developed it, and New Haven is within a stone’s throw from Long Island Sound, so they should. It is at the height of its game when served with their smoky bacon and a mix of clams, shredded aged cheese, and garlic over a thin crust that is baked to perfection.
Foxon Park soda
- Despite the fact that they are not strictly a part of the pizza, these pops are an important element of the New Haven experience.
- In addition to being prevalent at the major three, Foxon Park sodas, which have been made in East Haven since 1922, are also available at smaller convenience stores.
- They are well-known for its White Birch taste, which is achieved by the use of genuine sugar.
- Three generations have left a hat trick of Italian American pizza parlors in New Haven, as well as a history that motivates others to follow in their footsteps.
- Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, often known as Pepe’s, was the first restaurant to open on Wooster Street in 1925.
- Modern Apizza began on State Street in 1934, and Sally’s Apizza opened on Wooster Street in 1938, following in the footsteps of Pepe’s.
As pizzerias come and go, none have been able to ascend to the level of these three titans, but a few famous establishments, such as the new child on the block Bar, have come close.Here it is, the ultimate guide to New Haven’s pizza, as follows:
- Founded in the year 1938 Oven: a brick oven driven by coal.
- Tomato pie and Garden pie are two of our signature pizzas.
- Locate the restaurant at 237 Wooster Street in New Haven, Connecticut 06511, and visit sallysapizza.net for more information.
- Notes: Only cash will be accepted.
- Frank Sinatra was a big fan of Sally’s.
- And, essentially, that’s all there is to know about it.
Almost little has changed at Sally’s since Salvatore Consiglio first started selling pies from his coal-fired oven on Wooster Street in 1938.The Consiglio family continues to be the keeper of the Sally’s flame, and Salvatore Consiglio’s two sons, Richard and Bobby, continue to prepare the pies and wield the peels on a daily basis for the establishment.This exceptional integrity translates into a level of consistency that distinguishes Sally’s from any of its New Haven competitors.In all likelihood, the pizza you ate during your initial visit is same to the pizza you consume during your subsequent visit, which is likely to be comparable to the pizza that Ol’ Blue Eyes ate during his earlier visits.
Sally’s dining room, which is lined with wood paneling, is a reflection of decades of gathered mementos, and it leads to the controlled anarchy that is the rear open kitchen.The soot has smeared the white and red brick oven façade, containers and receipts are heaped perilously on the floor, and service is, well, nearly nonexistent.Approximately one metric ton of coal is consumed by Sally’s Restaurant each week, according to Bobby Consiglio.
One thing is certain: Sally’s tomato pie is the best tomato pie on Wooster Street, and no other pie can compare.This tomato pie is the gold standard by which all other tomato pies are judged, thanks in part to a house-made tomato sauce created from a proprietary combination of tomatoes.Simply charred edges, a thin coating of delicious tomato sauce that approaches the pizza’s flat border, and a scattering of fresh herbs, with not a fleck of cheese in sight, demonstrate that little is more and that decades of tradition are important when it comes to pizza-making.
A fresh tomato version with fresh basil and a little sprinkling of cheeses is available throughout the summer months at Sally’s.Other pies that are almost as wonderful as and distinctively Sally’s include the Garden Special, which is a blend of tomato, mozzarella, zucchini, and basil.Customers are divided by Sally’s well-worn patina and gruff quirkiness, with some finding her offensive while others finding her endearing.Sally’s, in contrast to Pepe’s, has been steadfastly focused and unmodified by the Consiglio family for the past 76 years.
- This might be the source of the rivalry between these two New Haven apizza parlors, which are eerily identical but diametrically opposed.
Pepe’s Pizzeria Napoletana
- The year 1925 marked the establishment of the company.
- a brick oven that has been burned with coal White clam pizza is our signature dish.
- Pepe’s Pizzeria is located at 157 Wooster Street in New Haven, Connecticut.
- Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, which is synonymous with New Haven pizza, is considered the ″granddaddy″ of the city’s pizza culture.
- It all started with a single store on Wooster Street in 1925, but Pepe’s has lately expanded to include five other sites in Connecticut and New York.
- Although a great deal of effort and money has been invested in replicating the flavor and feel of the Pepe’s experience, none of them come close to the original Pepe’s site in New Haven.
This is the location of the original Pepe’s, which is now known as The Spot and is to the left and rear of where Pepe’s is currently located on Wooster Street.There’s a smaller, virtually identical business with shorter queues in the building, but Pepe’s proper is still the primary attraction there.″ Two dining rooms are always packed to capacity, with huge queues frequently extending down the street in front of the establishment.A enormous and deep brick oven with a white-tiled exterior stands at attention in the back, surrounded by white-aproned men holding impossibly long peels and hammering out their rectangular pies that are as big as their heads.It was tomato pies that served as the basis for Pepe’s first pizzas, and the ″Original Tomato Pie″ neon sign that hangs over the kitchen counter as a continual reminder of their humble beginnings.
The iconic original white clam pie is the company’s most popular pizza.In an attempt to replicate the intoxicating mix of romano cheese, fresh garlic, olive oil, parsley, and clams on the chewy and lightly charred rectangular pizzas, hundreds of imitators have tried and failed.What’s the best way to make clam pizza?
Toss in some bacon.In addition to its strongly smoked bacon, Pepe’s is noted for its soft, malleable bacon that is comparable in texture to the clams, making it a great accomplice in the crime.
- Founded in the year 1934 Brick oven with an open flame for cooking (originally coke-fueled).
- The Italian Bomb is our signature pizza.
- Modern Pizza is located at 4 State Street in New Haven, Connecticut.
- For more information, visit modernapizza.com.
- In the East Rock neighborhood of New Haven, on State Street, Modern Apizza is a hidden gem just off the well-traveled path of Wooster Street.
- With an 80-year history and a commitment to apizza tradition, Modern Apizza has earned its place in the city’s pizza scene.
Modern Apizza is a hidden gem in the city’s pizza scene.Modern’s owner, Bill Pustari, who bought the business from its original owner more than thirty years ago, has worked diligently to establish the business’s reputation as a result of its position.As a result, it is often regarded as the most hospitable and family-friendly of the three major cities.The Italian Bomb is the name of the restaurant’s famous pie.
Modern’s open-flame brick oven produces pizzas that are charred, chewy, and robust in texture.The greater the number of toppings, the better.Because of the distinct texture of its undercarriage, the crust of New Haven apizza is one of the more fascinating on the market..
While other pizza parlors use cornmeal to aid in the removal of the pizza from the peel, Modern employs a proprietary breadcrumb concoction.If you pay attention to the motion in the oven, you’ll see that each pizza touches down on a rough surface before making its way into a pizza box, where the leftovers are cleared away.The thin and chewy Modern crust is the product of a dough created from a starter, which contains only flour, water, yeast, olive oil, and salt, and which is then subjected to a 24-hour cold fermentation in the refrigerator.
Modern is not afraid to utilize cheese, which is a whole milk aged mozzarella, and every Modern pie is topped with a sprinkling of Pecorino Romano cheese.In order to maintain uniformity, the sauce is created with whole hand-crushed Italian peeled tomatoes, which are typically purchased in bulk to assure consistency.The sauce cooks only while it is in the oven.To distinguish it from its more sparsely topped neighbors as well as classic pies, Modern’s most well-known pie has become known as the Italian Bomb, a monstrous pie that includes seven toppings: sausage, bacon, pepperoni, onion, mushrooms, and garlic, all made possible by the pie’s sturdy crust and sparing ″mootz.″ Modern Pizza, the underdog of New Haven’s pie scene, has the titles of ″friendliest″ restaurant and heaviest pizza, as well as being one of the few spots where you can typically escape a significant wait time.
- Update: Here’s an interview with Bill Pustari, the business’s owner.
- The year 1996 marked the beginning of the company’s existence.
- GasSignature in the Oven Pie is made using mashed potatoes (with bacon) Located at 254 Crown Street in New Haven, Connecticut 06510; barnightclub.com.
- Note: House-brewed beer and salads are available.
- When it comes to visitors, Pepe’s is for pizza purists, Sally’s is for the hipster 20-something community, and Modern is for the locals, Bar is for the hipster 20-something community (Yale is just one of its several university neighbors, after all).
- In addition to a limited but respectable range of house brewed beers, a large industrial-feeling area, and an unrivaled mashed potato (and bacon) pie, the bar takes pride in being the younger, brasher, new kid on the block in New Haven.
- The location of Bar, as well as its enormous area, are unbeatable.
The wide glass windows on the front of the building let light from Crown Street to flood into the Bru room, providing a glimpse of their renowned neighbor, Louis Lunch (home of the first hamburger).Nighttime uses include a brew pub and nightclub, which are both popular.The true lure at Bar, though, is the pizza, which differs significantly from the offerings of the elder statesmen in a number of important ways.The pies are much thinner, to the point of being practically impossible to cut.
Their rectangular forms are a reflection of the rectangular aluminum sheet pans on which they are served.When cut across, they abandon the wedge in favor of a rectangular slice, which is more traditional.They also provide non-pizza options (a single, and solid, salad).
Natural gas, not coal or oil, is used to heat the brick oven, unlike its New Haven counterparts.The mashed potato pie is by far the most well-known and much sought-after pizza in Bar (preferably with bacon and garlic).Yes, you read that correctly: mashed potatoes.
First and foremost, in order to appreciate Bar’s mashed potato and bacon pie, you must put aside any memories of mashed potatoes from your childhood that weren’t garlicky, light as air, sprinkled with a little aged cheese and herbs, and studded with crunchy chunks of bacon.Put on top of Bar’s unbelievable thin and light, crispy dough, this pizza completely changes the perception of what is possible with a pie.
New York Pizza vs. New Haven Apizza – Slice Pizza Blog
- When Frank Sinatra was at his peak, the world was truly his oyster.
- Alternatively, we may say – his clam chowder pie.
- Overall, the Rat Pack superstar sold more than 150 million albums, won every award under the sun, and produced some of the most legendary ballads of all time, including ″New York, New York,″ which is still performed today.
- That implies Sinatra could eat anything he wanted, whenever he wanted, even pizza, at any time.
- In the days leading up to his most important performances in New York City, Sinatra would order delivery from Sally’s…a restaurant in New Haven, Connecticut.
- True to form, even when Sinatra woke up in the city that never sleeps, he made sure to put the pizza of New Haven, Connecticut, at the top of his list of must-eats.
The lord of the manor.First and foremost.(I’m sure you get the picture.) Is this to imply that New Haven’s pizza is genuinely superior to New York’s in quality?Before you delve in to see whether you view things the same way as Ol’ Blue Eyes, have a look at our Styles Spotlight to see how they vary.
- For starters, the form of a pizza made in New Haven against a pizza made in New York will be noticeable as a first difference.
- The New York pie is as spherical as the stage of Madison Square Garden.
- A more accurate description of the New Haven pie would be ″roundish.″ For the New Haven pie, there is no genuine regular shape — some are oblong, while others are in the shape of an asymmetrical circular, depending on the store that manufactures them and the whims of the chef on any particular day.
- Whether your New Haven pie is lopsided or not, you can be confident that it will be split into triangles and come out darn near flawless, no matter what.
- Both crusts are crispy, but the chewiness of the New Haven-style crust is what distinguishes it.
- Because New Haven’s dough has been fermented for a longer period of time, there is a noticeable difference between the two crusts.
- New Haven crust, which is proofed gently overnight in the refrigerator, tends to be more nuanced in taste than its enormous New York cousin.
- For the most part, New York-style pizzas are constructed using a quick-rise dough that can be folded into a pie shell.
- The fold is a crucial distinguishing feature of the style; some argue that if a slice does not fold, it is not truly a New York slice in the traditional sense.
- As a matter of fact, the New York slice is so collapsible that Tony Manero was able to stack two of those bad boys together and fold them while strolling along 86th Street.
Some believe that the tap water in New York is the key to the fold’s success.NYC’s ″softer″ water contains lower quantities of calcium and magnesium than water from other parts of the world, as well as a little amount of additional salt, and some pizzaiolos believe that this is the secret to creating a crust that is both springy and crispy.The doughs are distinct in flavor and texture, but they both come out crispy on the bottom as a result of the extremely high oven temperatures used to prepare them.In New York-style pies, the temperature is usually between 500 and 600 degrees in gas-powered ovens, but in New Haven-style pies, the temperature is 650 degrees or higher.
A first-time visitor to New Haven could be perplexed as to whether the bottom of the pizza has been scorched.You may rest confident that it is not the case.In order to get the blistered and delightful char that is the genuine signature of a superb New Haven pie, we bake the New Haven pizza for an additional 15 minutes.
- ATTENTION: New Haven newcomers: Please do not return your pizza because it appears to be lacking in cheese.
- New Haven-style pizza adheres to the principle of ″less is more″ in its preparation.
- In order to highlight the delicate flavor of the crust and the acidic tomato sauce, the earliest pies made in New Haven were topped just with tomato sauce and no cheese.
- The cheese on New Haven-style pizza is kept to a minimum, which means a sprinkle of grated cheese unless you expressly want ″mootz″ (meatballs) on your pizza.
- New York-style pizza, on the other hand, is densely packed with cheese, with thin slices of low-moisture mozzarella covering the entire pie all the way up to the cornicione.
- You have no option between a New York or a New Haven pie for supper if you’re searching for an Instagram-worthy cheese pull and you’re selecting between a New York or a New Haven pie.
In addition to getting a lot of likes, making the trek to New Haven for pizza will also gain you a lot of likes.
- You might not be able to tell the difference between the sauces used on New York-style and New Haven-style pizzas by looking at them, but you’ll definitely notice it by tasting.
- Pizza sauce in New York is liberally seasoned with aromatics such as garlic, basil, oregano, dried pepper flakes, and red pepper flakes to balance out the sweetness and acidity of the tomatoes.
- According to New Haven sauce, it is important to retain the natural sweetness of San Marzano tomatoes by using less aromatics and spices in the recipe.
- Given the fact that there are no limits when it comes to pizza, you may order a New Haven-style pie with plenty of cheese and toppings, just as you would find on a New York-style pie, if that’s what you’re looking for.
- Modern Apizza, for example, crams its iconic Italian Bomb with mozzarella, sausage, bacon, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, bell peppers, and garlic onto a 12-inch pizza crust.
- Still, if you want to get a genuine taste of New Haven, you should try the legendary white clam pie, which is made with grated Romano cheese, fresh garlic, olive oil, parsley, and freshly-shucked, barely-briny, and surprisingly-sweet bivalves, along with other ingredients.
- In this case, there’s no need to add sauce or more cheese, but adding bacon will increase the smokiness and textural contrast, which is a pro move that many New Haveners swear by.
Pizza vs. Apizza
- Keep in mind that your New Haven-style pie has been scorched, not burnt.
- In addition, if you want mozzarella, you must purchase a pie that contains mootz.
- Oh, and there’s one more thing: in New Haven, it’s not referred to as pizza.
- It’s called apizza, which is pronounced ″ah-beetz.″ A homage to the dialect of the Neapolitan immigrants who brought pizza to the region when it was originally introduced is represented by the word ″apizza.″ In addition to the chewy crust, minimalistic tomato sauce, and lighter touch of cheese, it is only one of the many ways that New Haven-style pizza maintains its connection to its heritage.
- Don’t worry, the staff at Sally’s, Pepe’s, Modern Apizza, and the rest of New Haven’s well-known restaurants will still understand what you’re talking about if you order a ″pizza″ or fall into New York terminology and want a ″pie.″ However, if you want to fit in with the locals, you may say ″ah-beetz″ and park your vehicle someplace off of Wooster Street with your out-of-state license plate.
Hail To The King: Connecticut Pizza Again Named No. 1 In Nation
- Continue to the main content Bridgeport, CT
- Stratford, CT
- Fairfield, CT
- Trumbull, CT
- Milford, CT
- Westport, CT
- Weston-Redding-Easton, CT
- Monroe, CT
- Orange, CT
- Shelton-Derby, CT
- Bridgeport, CT
- Stratford, CT
- Fairfield, CT
- Trumbull, CT
- Milford, CT
- Bridgeport, CT
- Bridgeport, CT
- Bridgeport, CT
- Bridgeport, CT
- Bridgeport, CT
- Top National News
- See All Communities
Connecticut is a state in the northeastern United States.In The Daily Meal’s 101 Best Pizzas in America list, New York claimed 21 of the top pizzerias in the country, but Connecticut can once again boast that New Haven’s Frank Pepe’s Pizzeria Napoletana serves the best pizza in the country for the fourth consecutive year, making it the state with the best pizza in the country.″Dynasty,″ says the wind, as if to confirm.One Connecticut pizzeria has been added to the list, while another has been removed from the list, which was published this week.BAR from New Haven’s famed pizza mecca greets you as you enter at No.
47.However, Derby’s Roseland Apizza, which was placed No.51 on the Daily Meal rankings last year, has fallen out of favor.
Find out what’s happening in Across Connecticutwith free, real-time updates from Patch.
Pizzerias in Connecticut that were included in the Daily Meal’s 2020 list include: No.47 BAR (New Haven), No.45 Zuppardi’s Apizza (West Haven), No.43 Colony Grill (Stamford), No.16 Modern Apizza (New Haven), No.
9 Sally’s Apizza (New Haven), and No.1 Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana (New Haven) (New Haven).As soon as you get passed New York’s 21 competitors, the remainder of the list is all over the place.Illinois topped the list with six pizza establishments, followed closely by California and Nevada, both of which had five establishments.
Find out what’s happening in Across Connecticutwith free, real-time updates from Patch.
- The Daily Meal’s favorite pie may be found at Pepe’s once again. ″Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana is a household name among pizza enthusiasts all across the world,″ according to The Daily Meal. ″The New Haven-based pizzeria is most known for its unique coal-fired White Clam Pizza, which is made with fresh clams, grated pecorino romano, garlic, oregano, and extra virgin olive oil. Besides being the best pizza joint in America, Frank Pepe’s is also considered to be one of the finest old-school eateries of all time.″ It has been ranking America’s greatest pizzas since 2012, with The Daily Meal stating that ″it might sometimes feel like there is a pizzeria around every corner, but there’s just something about a fantastic pizza.″ ″We took great effort to showcase pizzerias from different sections of the country, as well as female- and Black-owned companies,″ the editors noted, emphasizing smaller shops and local favorites that had been successful in expanding to a few locations. According to the editors o